Too Faced

Butterscotch in other brands

Peach Perfect Comfort Matte Foundation – Peaches and Cream Collection · Liquid and cream

Depth: Lighter than 33% of the shades in our data
Undertone: Listed as warm from its retail listing
Swatch: Reads cooler than most shades this deep #d88159
Data: Retailer swatch, January 2021 (how we collect it)

Listed as warm, but its swatch reads cooler than most shades this deep. Retailer swatches don't always show undertone well, so give the listed undertone more weight.

The closest shade in another brand is Dior 050 Dark Beige in Diorskin Forever Undercover Foundation (likely close). In all, 30 ranges have a likely-close shade and 99 brands have one worth trying.

Closest shade in each brand

The 40 closest of 99 brands. The other 59 brands are listed below.

One shade per brand, closest first. Labels: Likely close under 4.5, Worth sampling 4.5 to 10. What these mean.

Dior

050 Dark Beige · Diorskin Forever Undercover Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Winky Lux

Deep · Diamond Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Bobbi Brown

8 Walnut · Skin Weightless Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
MAC

NW55 · Studio Fix Powder Plus Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Yves Saint Laurent

B80 · Touche Eclat All-In-One Glow Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
J.Cat Beauty

Sunkissed · Skinsurance Max Coverage Silky Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Ulta Beauty

Deep Warm · Adjustable Coverage Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Too Faced

Natural Beige · Born This Way Matte 24 Hour Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed neutral
Smith & Cult

360 Neutral · Veiled Threat Weightless Micro-Blurring Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed neutral
Charlotte Tilbury

12 COOL · Airbrush Flawless Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed cool
Il Makiage

212-66135 135 · Woke Up Like This Flawless Base Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
KVD Vegan Beauty

58 Medium W · Lock-It Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
UOMA Beauty

T1W Brown Sugar · Say What?! Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads deeper and warmer · listed warm
Milani

Warm Sand · Conceal + Perfect Smooth Finish Cream-To-Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
Natasha Denona

RN7 - Tan Dark Rosy Neutral · Hy-Glam Serum Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-cool
Fenty Beauty

370 · Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed neutral-warm
NARS

MD3.15 Seville · Natural Radiant Longwear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
Lancôme

440 Bisque · Dual Finish Multi-Tasking Lightweight Pressed Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer
KIKO Milano

Hazelnut · Tuscan Sunshine Luminous Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer
L'Oréal

505 - Toffee · Infallible 32 Hour Lightweight Fresh Wear Longwear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer
Maybelline

338 Spicy Brown · Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Laura Mercier

6C1 · Tinted Moisturizer Broad Spectrum SPF 20 - Oil Free

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
ILIA

14 Dominica · Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40 Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Estée Lauder

5W1 Bronze · Futurist Hydra Rescue Moisturizing Makeup SPF 45

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
Makeup Revolution

F10.5 · Conceal & Glow Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
rms beauty

66 · "Un" Cover-Up Cream Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Tarte

45H tan honey · face tape foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
jane iredale

M11 · Beyond Matte Liquid Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed neutral
Rare Beauty

390C · Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper · listed neutral
Make Up For Ever

R520Cinnamon · Matte Velvet Skin Blurring Powder Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Clinique

CN 113 Sepia · Even Better Refresh Hydrating and Repairing Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper and warmer · listed neutral-cool
Wet n Wild

Amber · PhotoFocus Stick Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer
Juvia's Place

420 Havana · I Am Magic Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed warm
It Cosmetics

Deep · Celebration Full Coverage Powder Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper
Cover FX

P60 · Power Play Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
ZOEVA

300N Joy · Authentik Skin Natural Luminous Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads warmer · listed olive
Nudestix

6 Nude · Tinted Cover Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-warm
Catrice

046 Neutral Toffee · True Skin Hydrating Foundation

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper · listed neutral
bareMinerals

22 Warm Tan · Matte Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 15

Worth sampling Swatch reads deeper and warmer · listed warm
Sephora Collection

13 Walnut · Make No Mistake Foundation & Concealer Stick

Worth sampling Swatch reads cooler · listed olive

Closest shade in the other 59 brands

A to Z by brand. The 40 above are closer; open a shade to see how close it is.

Filter every range in the shade finder

Next to it in Peach Perfect Comfort Matte Foundation – Peaches and Cream Collection

Chestnut (lighter)
Sable (deeper)

Colours come from retailer swatch photos taken in January 2021. Test a shade on your jaw in daylight before you buy.