Tarte

58H rich honey in other brands

Depth: Lighter than 7% of the shades in our data
Undertone: Listed as warm on the brand's website
Swatch: Reads in between warm and cool #7b4c32
Data: Tarte's own website, October 2026 (how we collect it)

The closest shade in another brand is Fenty Beauty 450 in Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Powder Foundation (likely close). In all, 120 ranges have a likely-close shade and 91 brands have one worth trying.

Closest shade in each brand

The 40 closest of 91 brands. The other 51 brands are listed below.

One shade per brand, closest first. Labels: Likely close under 4.5, Worth sampling 4.5 to 10. What these mean.

Fenty Beauty

450 · Pro Filt'r Soft Matte Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Morphe

F4.70 Warm · Fluidity Full-Coverage Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Catrice

085 Chestnut Beige · HD Liquid Coverage Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
NYX Professional Makeup

Mocha · Total Control Pro Drop Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Make Up For Ever

R510 · Ultra HD Invisible Cover Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
MAC

NW50 · Studio Fix Fluid SPF 15 24HR Matte Foundation + Oil Control

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
bareMinerals

30 Deepest Deep · Matte Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 15

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Il Makiage

212-66230 230 · Woke Up Like This Flawless Base Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Becca Cosmetics

Mahogany · Skin Love Weightless Blur Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Dose Of Colors

131 Dark · Meet Your Hue Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-cool
L.A. Girl

Rich Cocoa · Pro Coverage Liquid Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Laura Mercier

Truffle · Flawless Lumière Radiance-Perfecting Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
La Mer

420 Terra · The Soft Fluid Long Wear Foundation SPF 20

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
Beauty Bakerie

307 Cool Neutral · InstaBake Aqua Glass Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-cool
e.l.f. Cosmetics

54 Deep Neutral · Soft Glam Satin Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
NARS

New Caledonia · Soft Matte Complete Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Dermablend

80N Cinnamon · Smooth Liquid Camo Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-cool
Estée Lauder

7C1 Rich Mahogany · Double Wear Stay-in-Place Makeup

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
KIKO Milano

Cocoa · Tuscan Sunshine Luminous Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
L'Oréal

Nut Brown/Cocoa · True Match Lumi Healthy Luminous Makeup

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
Armani Beauty

16 · Neo Nude Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed olive
Benefit Cosmetics

Shade 12 · Hello Happy Air Stick Foundation SPF 20

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
PÜR

Deep · 4-In-1 Foundation Stick

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-warm
BLK/OPL

Carob · TRUE COLOR Pore Perfecting Crème Powder Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same
KVD Vegan Beauty

080 Deep · True Portrait Medium Coverage Shake Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral
It Cosmetics

58 Deep Neutral · Your Skin But Better Foundation + Skincare

Likely close Swatch reads cooler · listed neutral
Clinique

WN 124 Sienna · Stay Matte Oil-Free Makeup

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed neutral-warm
Pat McGrath Labs

33 Deep · Sublime Perfection Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Milani

Golden Toffee · Conceal + Perfect 2-in-1 Foundation + Concealer

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Dior

080 Ebony · Diorskin Forever Undercover Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads cooler · listed neutral
Tarte

58S Rich Sand · Babassu Foundcealer Skincare Foundation Broad Spectrum SPF 20

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Elcie Cosmetics

Almond · Micro Silque Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Bobbi Brown

10.25 Cool Espresso · Skin Foundation SPF 15

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed cool
Urban Decay

12.0 · All Nighter Liquid Full Coverage Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads cooler · listed warm
Rare Beauty

510W · Liquid Touch Weightless Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed olive
Marc Jacobs Beauty

86 Cocoa Deep · Re(marc)able Full Cover Foundation Concentrate

Likely close Swatch reads cooler · listed cool
Lancôme

540 Suede W · Teint Idole Ultra Wear 24H Long Wear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Lorac

24 · PRO Soft Focus Longwear Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads about the same · listed warm
Yves Saint Laurent

B95 · All Hours Longwear Natural Matte Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads cooler · listed neutral
UOMA Beauty

T2N Black Pearl · Say What?! Foundation

Likely close Swatch reads deeper · listed neutral

Closest shade in the other 51 brands

A to Z by brand. The 40 above are closer; open a shade to see how close it is.

Filter every range in the shade finder

Next to it in face tape foundation

57S rich sand (lighter)
59S rich sand (deeper)

Colours come from Tarte's own website, checked October 2026. Test a shade on your jaw in daylight before you buy.